Sue de Beer and Laura Parnes: Double Your Transgression, Double Your Fun

Tom Moody
VERY Magazine, Fall, 1999, pp. 16-17
[link] [link]

parnes - de beer

In their 1992 video Heidi, artists Paul McCarthy and Mike Kelley turned the classic tale of a young girl’s coming of age into a three-ring circus of family dysfunction. In this orgy of obsessive-compulsive behavior interspersed with lofty Socratic dialogues on the relationship of nature and culture, Grandpa, a sadistic paternal figure, teaches Heidi and her brother Peter what they need to know to grow and thrive in the adult world: how to read, how to get beaten up, how to push sausages out of your ass. Now New York-based artists Laura Parnes and Sue de Beer have given the story a media-saturated spin in a two-channel video installation titled Heidi 2. As the script notes, the new production "is not a critique or on homage but a sequel, and follows the roles of any good sequel: more blood, additional celebrities, and more special effects."

The video begins with a disgusting birth scene suggesting a cross between Cindy Sherman’s sex toy photos and the monster births in Larry Cohen’s "It’s Alive" films. The character of Heidi later appears as both mother and daughter, played by the two artists in rubber Charlie Brown and Pigpen masks, Grandpa is reduced to a bit player and Leonardo de Caprio (an actor in a cardboard mask) fulfills the celebrity quota. Mocking parenting in the age of rampant bulimia and art school instruction in the age of Abjection 101, Heidi 1 shows Heidi 2 how to projectile vomit (“Like this?” daughter asks -- big splash -- ”No, that’s too self-conscious,” mom replies) and at the climax of the tape, how to “self-operate.” In this disturbingly affectless scene, combining radical weight-reduction surgery with Teletubbies-style auto-surveillance, Heidi 2’s stomach is cut out, tossed into a bucket, and replaced with a TV monitor carrying her image in a continuous live feed.

To those familiar with the artists' work, Heidi 2 is an intriguing marriage of sensibilities. Parnes’ video No Is Yes, 1998, limns a more straightforward (but equally depraved) narrative in which two teenage girls murder a misogynist punk rocker in a Thelma and Louise-style face-off, give him a Clueless-style makeover (stripping him nude, tying him up, adorning him with knife-inflicted scratch-iti), and then ask their mentor, a dominatrix named Sarah, for Pulp Fiction-style help in disposing of the body. (“Who do you think I am, Harvey Keitel?” Sarah asks). Enlivened by quick editing and MTV-style inserts, No ls Yes is a teen rebellion film reinterpreted for a gallery context and its bleak message -- that rebellion in a world of commodified nihilism is meaningless -- echoes through­out Heidi 2.

De Beer, in her own solo work, has a flair for catchy, surrealistic images, resembling the shock iconography of fashion and advertising (e.g. Diesel’s recent “dead teenagers” campaign) but with a creepy, personal vibe. Through low-budget f/x, including digitally altered videos and C-prints, she has depicted herself as a pair of clones in a languid make-out session, an ax-murder victim split from skull to sternum, and an impossibly long-legged Frankenwaif straining to touch the floor with her fingertips. Although arrived at collaboratively with Pames, Heidi 2’s vomiting scene -- with its doppelganger composition and obvious Exorcist reference -- recalls de Beer’s characteristic union of horror-movie scenes and choreographed body art pathologies.

This immersion in media and popular culture sets Parnes and de Beer apart from an older generation of performance artists (McCarthy, Schneeman, Nitsch), who seek to heal a split between a “repressed, cultural” self and an “authentic, natural” self through ritualistic acts of transgression (fecal smearing, orgiastic sex, and so on). In de Beer’s and Parnes’ view, no split exists because everything is mediated: the most extreme acts can be found on tape at the corner video store and “real” experience is suspect. Rejecting the superior vantage point of the artist/shaman, the artists use pop culture tropes without apology, expressing the most “primal” events -- childbirth, orgasm, incestuous rape -- in the idiom of sitcoms, video games, and splatter films.

New Jersey Wasteland Tour, 2003

The photos and commentary below originally appeared as a slide show, linked from my old blog on Digital Media Tree [post and comments] [slide show] [update]
The New Jersey wasteland in question is the acreage between Grand Avenue and Liberty State Park in Jersey City, an industrial zone that had gone to seed and would eventually become condos. In 2019, when I last visited the area, the park itself sported healthier-looking tree cover, while the canal basin appeared less ugly but still "transitional." The rickety footbridge across the canal inlet survived until Hurricane Sandy flooding destroyed it; a much sturdier metal bridge is there now. The city tore down the concrete plant and scrapyard buildings but a garbage barge or two still anchors nearby. They finished the road but it connects nothing to nowhere.
A surveyor told me that development of the area has stalled because of two factors: (i) it sits in the 100 year floodplain and no amount of legal redefinition/jerrymandering can change that and (ii) the end of the canal, near the bridge, has outlets for emergency sewage overflow. Meaning that when the system is strained they periodically discharge raw sewage into the canal.

So, here is my photo-essay from 2003, unaltered:

 

1_2281

Our tour begins near the intersection of Grand St. and Jersey Ave. This decrepit structure sits across the avenue from a sleek new Medical Center currently under construction. Someone told me it was a crack den, but whatever--Little House on the Prairie it ain't. Like many dwellings in areas developers are keen to take over, this one recently had a "mysterious fire." I'm betting it won't last through 2003.

 

2_2287

Just past the "crack house" is a stop for the newly constructed New Jersey Light Rail, which runs north-south from Hoboken to Bayonne. This is rose-tinted urban planning at its finest, completely out of step with the overall desolation of the area. Note the profusion of flyers in the kiosk and all the bikes in the bike racks.

 

3_2284

After the light rail stop, we walk past a (still active) concrete plant and a car-crushing facility. Now we're getting into the scary part. I call this the "recycling depot" but I really don't know what it is. It looks abandoned and is missing a good deal of the roof, but trucks still go in and out of the gates. Once I saw some cute girls in bikini bottoms and leather jackets doing a fashion shoot here, posing behind a chain link fence. I guess the art director thought the place looked punk. Oh, yeah, in the background is the Liberty Science Center, which has an IMAX theatre.

 

4_2282

This, for me, is the high point of the tour--walking across the foetid Morris Canal on a rickety footbridge! The canal isn't really a canal anymore, just an inlet with decaying docks and a year-round ripe sewer smell. In the summer you have to walk really fast across this bridge before the mosquitoes completely drain you.

 

5_2291

Between the footbridge and the entrance to Liberty State Park lay a neglected grassy area that was always a pleasure to walk through. Not anymore! The state has been busy the past few months paving over the whole strip and putting in a fairly useless looking cul-de-sac. What you see here is a wheelchair/bike ramp, under construction obviously, connecting the cul-de-sac and the footbridge. God only knows what new construction horrors await us. Seeing this last week actually gave me the impetus to do this tour, because I realized the little zone of rot I walk through is about to succumb to the attentions of the fixer-uppers. As much as I make fun of the decay in this area, I think its beautification will be worse. My solution would be: Just leave it alone, people! Let nature make it beautiful again, not you.

 

6_2285

Skirting the cul-de-sac, we turn left and enter Liberty State Park, an enormous open expanse that's been under threat from developers since its inception. So far neighborhood activists have managed to halt plans for a golf course, a water park, and an amphitheatre on this property, which is reclaimed railroad and industrial land. That's the Manhattan skyline dead ahead, looking rather romantic in the rain. To the left is an approximately 10 acre grassy sward that was paved over and then unpaved after 9/11. Ostensibly the lot was for "emergency ferry parking" after Osama knocked out the PATH stop under the Trade Center, but--surprise--no traffic ever materialized. What seemed good for the country in that dire state of emergency was also good for the Tony Soprano Asphalt Company and its related entity, the Junior Soprano Asphalt Removal Company. Also note the spindly little trees added to the reseeded lawn.

 

7_2283

Strolling down the cobblestone street in the middle of nowhere, we see Lady Liberty off to the south (hence the name Liberty State Park). On the other side of the fence is marshland that's reportedly tainted with chromium from years when heavy industry dominated this area. Apparently there's an engineering plan on the boards to dredge and dig rivulets through the marsh and thereby restore it to an "authentic wetland." Christ, it just never stops.

 

8_2286

This is the mound of fill dirt left over from the paving/unpaving project, which I've been calling Mount Liberty. The state plopped this unseemly mass on top of the landscaped grass a year ago; about two thirds of it was used to cover the ex-parking lot and the rest just sits there, with no sign of imminent removal. Overgrown with weeds and still fringed with black plastic and orange security webbing, this hump is bigger than it looks in the photo; it's about twenty feet high, and when you climb on top of it you have a great view of New York Harbor. Maybe the state considers it an amenity now--or maybe they're just too broke to move it.

 

9_2278

Did Robert Smithson submit early designs for the park? No, it's not the Spiral Land Jetty. It's one of the many landscaped areas with stunted trees, plants that never seem to grow in right, and unused park benches. Actually the park's biggest users were absent the day I took these pictures: the lazy good-for-nothing "golf course geese"--idiot progeny of government breeding programs to restore the formerly endangered Canada Goose--who pad about leaving their droppings everywhere.

 

10_2290

By now you're probably thinking, "God, this guy's a cynic. He just hates everything." So I'm going to end the tour with some photos I took after the rain ended, and the afternoon sun was peeking back out. Here's a view of the scrapyard from the park side of the inlet. The docks are part of the marina those developers managed to slip past...No, I'm going to end nicely. I think this is a lovely picture, and I doff my cap to the technicians at Sony whose digital camera made it possible.

 

11_2289

Another pretty picture: the Jersey City skyline, Manhattan skyline, and marina from the park, near the footbridge.

 

12_2288

So we don't end on too sappy a note, here's the swampy side of the canal again, looking its toxic/fecal best, with rays of afternoon light hitting the Jersey Turnpike, off in the distance. Look now, and enjoy, because come the next economic upturn this will all spruced up and yuppified. Or maybe not.

Tom Moody, January 2, 2003

back to travel writing

aeon flux vhs vs dvd: Utopia or Deuteranopia

utopia_or_deuteranopia650w

screenshot from Bregna 2415 (resized) [dead link]

In the '90s, MTV, between the "shitty music video" era and the "spring breakers" era, briefly hosted some trippy animation. Aeon Flux emerged then, under the direction of Peter Chung, who was 30 at the time, with all imaginative pistons firing. Shortly thereafter MTV released the three seasons on VHS tape, and in 2005 Chung remastered the tapes and re-released them on DVD. To the annoyance of some fans, he added new dialog to four of the shows. He claimed this was to bring the characterizations of Aeon Flux and Trevor Goodchild "into better continuity with the series as a whole." New dialog was also written for the character "Clavius," former leader of Bregna. Three of the episodes he altered ("The Demiurge," "Reraizure," and "End Sinister") were directed by Howard E. Baker, a fourth (this one, "Utopia or Deuteranopia)," was directed by Chung himself. Here are some belated notes on the changes to:

Utopia or Deuteranopia
Presumably this means a better society, with or without rules. It should probably be spelled Deuteronopia, after the biblical book Deuteronomy
VHS DVD
Opening title includes the sentence "It's none of Aeon's business, but..." [sentence removed in DVD version]
Trevor Goodchild in voiceover:
There can be no justice where there is no truth. What is the truth? Tell me if you know and I will not believe you. Things are never what they seem. Clean gloves hide dirty hands, and mine are dirtier than most.
Trevor Goodchild in voiceover:
The unobserved state is a fog of probabilities. A window of and for error. The watcher observes; the fog collapses; an event resolves. A theory becomes a fact. What is the truth? Tell me if you know and I will not believe you. Things are never what they seem. Clean gloves hide dirty hands, and mine are dirtier than most. Without truth there can be no justice.
Aeon: My name is Aeon Flux. I’m here on a mission to assassinate Trevor Goodchild. Is everybody listening? Do you believe me? Am I confessing? Aeon: My name is Aeon Flux. I’m here on a mission to assassinate Trevor Goodchild. Is everybody listening? Do you believe me? Everybody happy?
Trevor, watching surveillance footage shot by his government's cameras:
So many people with so much to hide.
They know what's wrong and they don't listen.
These are the new rules: No more hiding. There's nothing to lose but shame, inhibition, perversion. All the good things in life.
Trevor, watching surveillance footage shot by his government's cameras:
What is this? Look, let's not even bother with those idiots, just show me some action.
[narrating action on video] Aah, going somewhere? Vacation -- for ten years?
[phonetic -- spoken over footage of bigwig being spanked by dominatrix] Counsel Gaiman!
You know the rules. Total information awareness. Equal opportunity enforcement. We are not losing anything but shame, inhibition, perversion, depravity, degeneracy, debauch... [interrupted]
Gildemere: Listen, I think I’m being watched. There are things I have to do. Keep this safe here. Gildemere: Listen, I think I’m being watched.
Aeon: You don’t miss a trick.
Gildemere: There are things I have to do. Keep this safe here.
Clavius, awakening from machine trance:
A bed... A hole... The crickets...
Clavius, awakening from machine trance:
I want out... I want out... ohh...
Clavius, watching surveillance footage from government prison cells:
Valentine, Orillian, Mustafa. Impossible. Diacono. What is this?
By locking them up, Trevor has shut down the flow of funds, you fool.
Not to mention that they're some of my best friends. Why is there no air in here?
Clavius, watching surveillance footage from government prison cells:
[phonetic] Paysok. Andrus. Turkaloo?! Who did this? They've rounded up the whole network!
By locking them up, Trevor has shut down our base of credit, you fool. These men are my special friends. Why is it so hot in here?
Clavius, talking with Gildemere:
No, the flying saucer men are the flying saucer men -- Nowzak! Galaxy 66! The evil empire! What's wrong with you? When the orbital jellyfish umbrella is deployed we'll have round-the-clock defensive capability.
Shut up, mother! [weeps, laughs]
Clavius, talking with Gildemere:
No, the flying saucer men are the flying saucer men -- Narzak! Area 66! The global empire! What level are you? We're men of peace so we attack. Deploy the orbital jellyfish. Next, expulsion of all foreign particles.
Shut up, mother!
We can do the air... Fecal matter... I don't know [weeps, laughs]

other comparisons: The Demiurge / Reraizure / End Sinister

Update: This is my own comparison and transcription, based on review of the VHS and DVD versions of this episode. After posting (sigh) I found this tumblr post [dead link]. I made a few tweaks to my chart based on that transcription.

Tyler Kline virtual (?) sculpture

tyler_kline1_650w

Tyler Kline, via twitter

This is a jpeg mini-review. Is this a virtual photo? A 3D printed object? Some hybrid of the two? What is the scale? No "materials" or dimensions are given. Regardless, it works for me as a piece, or a prospectus for one. Gestural energy, fecal texture, and quasi-crystalline structure merge into a hyperrealized idea of modernist sculpture. Like a '60s sf book cover in 3D space. The rectangular base suggests "sculpture" but also a painting surface from which this tangle of forms has somehow erupted. It's the kind of project I could imagine Frank Stella wanting to make, but always lacking the imagination or inner turmoil to achieve (Stella, in his "wrecked spaceship" period, mostly just artlessly clumps things together). The 3D sheen also gives the work a CGI horror movie vibe, a la Michael Bay Transformers. There is also a clone tool element, or a parody of the ease with which digital cloning allows the repetition of certain forms.

new site to-do list

or "bug" list (not sure which yet)

1. need self-designed "fecal molecule" favicon from previous blog design
2. "without comments" line needs to be hidden in individual post URLs
3. "without comments" line needs to be hidden in search results
4. reduce size of post titles?
5. change color of post titles?
6. delete blue frames around images that are also links, e.g.: this one
7. Separate links to my content from "blogroll," e.g. "my artwork," "tm at Nasty Nets"
8. Rename "blogroll"?
9. "posted by tom moody" instead of "Written by..."? [used "-tom moody" for post signatures]
10. More padding below post titles? (titles and images are almost merging, conceptually, at this point)

(work in process--sorry this is boring)